Collection 3 desert storm 19901991 5and operation iraqi freedom 2003. All geneva conventions entered into forced on 21 october, 1950. Geneva convention relative to the protection of civilian persons in time of war. Israeli soldiers use two palestinian minors as human shields. Abc news embeds on its website a military clip with the caption.
Use of human shields civilians who are used as human shields to protect military objectives or military operations are obviously placed in grave danger of becoming subject to attack. It is prohibited to seize or to use the presence of persons protected by the geneva conventions as human shields to render military sites immune from enemy attacks or to prevent reprisals during an offensive gciv arts. The prohibition of the use of civilians in warfare stems from both the geneva conventions and the additional protocols of 1977. Cameroons instructors manual 1992 prohibits the use of human shields as a. Human shields are often produced through acts of framing. Such voluntary shields are not morally liable to collateral harm, though less is required to justify collateral harm to them than to justify collateral harm to involuntary shields or to civilians who are merely in the. Article 51 of the first protocol states, the parties to the conflict shall not direct the movement. Dec 07, 2016 the use of human shields is not included as a grave breach of the geneva conventions or additional protocol i. Yet, in the book we maintain that this has to do also with the intimate relationship between speech, law and violence. In 1977, the two additional protocols were adopted in 2006, the icrc produced a study of 161 rules, most of which apply in all conflicts including those involving ansas.
Introduction to the law of armed conflict loac geneva call. The use of human shields violates the 1949 geneva conventions, which iraq has signed. Rockets and mortar shells are routinely fired from built up, densely populated areas and near structures and facilities including educational institutions and mosques provided special protection by the geneva conventions. Also referred to as the law of war or the law of armed conflict. The use of human shields is forbidden by protocol i of the geneva conventions. Indeed, the prohibition is designed to protect detainees from being exposed to the risk of. Voluntary human shields, direct participation in hostilities and the. Examples of definitions of humanitarian law violations.
Human shields are legally protected personseither civilians or prisoners of warwho are either coerced or volunteer to deter attacks by occupying the space between a belligerent and a legitimate military target. Common article 3 to the geneva conventions of 1949. Geneva convention iv, read with additional protocol i, refers to human shields as civilians or protected persons, whose presence or movement is aimed or used to render military targets immune from military operations. It also points to a more radical transformation in the history of human shielding, particularly. However, the icrc lists this conduct as a crime regardless of conflict classification.
The capture and forcible movement of hundreds of foreign nationals in iraq and kuwait to iraqicontrolled strategic sites. The 10 articles of the original 1864 version of the convention have been expanded in the first geneva convention of 1949 to 64. Hague geneva conventions law of occupation jus cogens human rights norms. Apr 18, 2017 geneva convention calls for protection of civilians.
Additional protocol i of the 1949 geneva conventions, which of all the ihl treaties. Capture of iaf officer geneva conventions on prisoners of war. Israel signed the fourth geneva convention on 8 december 1949 and ratified i 1951t on 6 th jul. Voluntary human shields, direct participation in hostilities and the international. It directs and coordinates the international activities conducted by the movement in armed conflicts and other situations of violence. Using human shields is a violation of international humanitarian law. Most examples given in military manuals, or which have been the object. Firing rockets, artillery, and mortars from or in proximity to heavily populated civilian areas, often from or near facilities which should be protected according to the geneva convention e. May 30, 2017 using one man as a human shield to safeguard 31 men and avoid innumerable fatalnonfatal civilian casualties was not a bad option. The interaction between international human rights law and. It is also a specific intent war crime as codified in the rome statute, which was adopted in 1998.
Summary of the geneva conventions of 1949 and their. The international committee of the red cross icrc study on customary international humanitarian law ihl summarizes the various prohibitions against using human shields contained in the third and fourth geneva conventions of 12 august 1949 gcs, in additional protocol i to the geneva conventions, relating to the protection of victims of international armed conflicts of 8 june 1977. Forcing noncombatants to serve as human shields is a war crime according to the 1949 geneva conventions, the 1977 additional protocol i to the geneva conventions, and the 1998 rome statute. Pdf human shields were prominent in the 2016 military campaign seeking to recapture mosul from the hands of isis militants. Pdf on jan 1, 2017, beth van schaack published human shields. Protocol additional to the geneva conventions of august 12, 1949, and relating to the protection of victims of international armed conflicts art. The problem of human shields in an international armed conflict is addressed in a number of provisions of the geneva conventions. The main source of humanitarian laws are the four geneva convention of 12 august 1949. A protections and rights the civilian immunity from direct attack is found in common art 3 of the geneva conventions the. Geneva conventions, and to all, military and civilians, for whose benefit the conventions. In the context of international armed conflicts, this rule is set forth in the third geneva convention with respect to prisoners of war, the fourth geneva. The presence of a protected person may not be used to render certain points or. Jun 30, 20 human shield tactics in war, but western and islamic theories have developed almost wholly within selfreferential frameworks. The geneva conventions are a body of international law designed to establish acceptable and humanitarian conduct under conditions of war and occupation.
Jan 08, 2009 the use of human shields in conflict is prohibited under the geneva conventions. Human shields by neve gordon, nicola perugini hardcover. Doctors without borders the practical guide to humanitarian law. From syrian civilians locked in iron cages to veterans joining peaceful indigenous water protectors at the standing rock sioux reservation, from sri lanka to iraq and from yemen to the united states, human beings have been used as shields for protection, coercion, or deterrence. Article 28 of the 1949 geneva convention iv provides. The only reservation israel made refers to the use of the red shield of david as the emblem and distinctive sign of its medical services, see reservations and declarations concerning the four geneva conventions of 12 august 1949. Palestinian civilians, protected under the geneva convention iv during its military operation, including the use of them as human shields against shooting and to search human shields. Article 3 of the geneva convention on treatment of pows deals with every kind of situation that may arise for a captive and captor. Fourth geneva convention relative to the protection of civilian.
My understanding that under the 4th geneva convention, the actions mentioned above goes against international conventions and therefore international law. There are four geneva conventions, established in 1949, and two additional protocols adopted in 1977. Strict prohibitions on the deployment of human shields in international armed conflicts can be found in the hague convention iv 1907, the geneva conventions iii and iv 1949 and the additional protocol i 1977, and most recently, the rome statute of the international criminal court 1998. The relevant framework consists of the geneva conventions of 1949, protocol i thereto, and. Western theorists resort to kant, to a secular utilitarianism styled on jeremy bentham, to treaty accords such as the geneva convention, or to christian notions of right and wrong. Geneva convention also expressly prohibits the use of civilians as human shields, and bans their physical or moral coercion to obtain information, which arguably also prohibits the coercive recruitment of children as informants. And given the options deterrence in the presence of human shields or pursuit of the military objective 100 percent of the time, the latter is the only option that disables human shield use as a functional behavior and effective strategy. Bbc news middle east gaza human shields criticised. Fdd how the use of human shields violates international law. Indeed, the prohibition is designed to protect detainees from being exposed to the risk of harm, and not only to the harm itself. Using protected detainees as human shields constitutes a violation of the provisions of the geneva conventions regardless of whether those human shields were actually attacked or harmed.
These four conventions were adopted on 12 august, 1949 at a conference convened in geneva for the establishment of international conventions for the protection of war victims. A protections and rights the civilian immunity from direct attack is found in common art 3 of the geneva conventions the minimum standard of protection for civilians in. Voluntary human shields in international humanitarian law. The capture and forcible movement of hundreds of foreign nationals in iraq and kuwait to iraqicontrolled strategic sites and the threat to use thousands of others similarly. Saddams exploitation of this tactic has encompassed.
The framing of women and children as human shields by state militaries is carried out not only to cover up the killing of innocent civilians in the era of drone warfare. The use of human shields and the principle of proportionality under the law of armed conflict. The geneva convention for the amelioration of the condition of the wounded and sick in armed forces in the field of august 12, 1949. Geneva convention relative to the protection of civilian persons in time of wa. United states and iraq are parties to the 1949 geneva conventions. If one party uses human shields, opposing forces must still assess whether the potential.
The use of human shields is not included as a grave breach of the geneva conventions. Situating human shields in the crimes of the colonists the 1949 geneva conventions pulled human shields into its black letter corpus through article 28 of the fourth geneva conventions. In 1864, the first geneva convention was adopted in 1949, the four geneva conventions as they stand today were adopted. The prohibition of using human shields in the geneva conventions, additional protocol i and the statute of the international criminal court are couched in terms of using the presence or movements of civilians or other protected persons to render certain points or areas or military forces immune from military operations. Lastly, the so called human rights model argues that all human shields must be considered fully when examining the military strikes and principle of proportionality iii. The geneva conventions and protocols try specifically to protect all human beings affected by armed conflict, especially those who are not, or no longer, directly engaged in hostilities.
Hospital shields and the limits of international law. Prisoners of war armed conflict geneva conventions 1949 military objectives combatants military necessity peace keeping published under the auspices of the max planck institute for comparative public law and international law under the direction of professor anne peters 2021 and professor rudiger wolfrum 20042020. The human shield and the ethics of noninternational armed. Israel signed the fourth geneva convention on 8 december 1949 and ratified it on 6 july 1951.
The 1949 geneva conventions sought to protect civilians in war to avoid a repeat of the horrific slaughter of civilians in world war ii. Addressing the use of human shields dam geneva centre for. Geneva convention relative to the treatment of prisoners of war, of. Jul 27, 2017 human shields also fall into this category and represent the illegal use of civilians to deter military operations. Api, article 85 listing other grave breaches giving rise to individual criminal responsibility. A chilling global history of the human shield phenomenon. Targeting decisions involving voluntary human shields in. Can end the use of human shields abstract the appropriate response to human shields is a recurring issue in modern warfare. Jan 04, 2017 9 convention iv respecting the laws and customs of war on land, with annex of regulations, oct. Oct 15, 2020 the use of civilians to shield military objectives from lawful attack or to deliberately cause civilian casualties is a war crime that violates the fourth geneva convention. It was precisely the accentuation of medical neutrality during the 1863 geneva conference that enabled dunant to convince the powerful countries of his time to sign the first geneva convention for the amelioration of the condition of the wounded in armies in the field 1864 geneva convention the following year. All countries are signatories to the geneva conventions.
1073 668 293 491 852 1110 344 829 560 1169 400 569 680 1009 636 255 799 204 122 1062 759 103 1244 405 1241 1357 957 1158 433 576 1369 210 962 169 417 958